13 defendants in khat smuggling case go to trial, allegedly imported $5M worth of the drug
Wednesday, 18 April 2012 14:05
Written by Amiin
ALEXANDRIA, Va. — Thirteen natives of Somalia and Yemen are on trial in federal court, accused of smuggling a drug common to their homelands but illegal in the U.S.
Authorities allege that for six years, the group smuggled millions of dollars’ worth of khat, a leaf that is popular in the region around Somalia and Yemen and can produce a mild high when chewed.
While a few defendants, including the two alleged ringleaders, have pleaded guilty, most of the accused are fighting the charges and going to trial. Jury selection began Tuesday; the trial is expected to at least three weeks.
The legal case may turn on technicalities, but it also presents a broader question of whether the government engaged in overkill by prosecuting otherwise law-abiding members of the Somali- and Yemeni-American communities for using a substance that is culturally accepted in their homelands and by some measures is no more potent than a caffeinated energy drink.
Prosecuting khat can be difficult for the government. Technically, khat itself is not illegal, but it’s the active ingredients in the leaf, cathine and cathinone that are controlled substances. Cathinone particularly is treated as a serious drug under federal law.
But cathinone is unstable and known to deteriorate rapidly after khat is harvested, often within 48 hours. Appellate courts have said that transporting khat itself is not a violation unless the government can prove that the khat actually contains either of the controlled substances.
In court papers, prosecutors have emphasized that the conspiracy took pains to rapidly import fresh khat once it was harvested because the conspirators knew that fresh khat was prized by users for providing a superior effect. But defense lawyers have challenged the government’s evidence as insufficient.
“The government must produce evidence of cathinone and not attempt to confuse and confound the jury by treating ‘khat’ and ‘cathinone’ as synonyms,” wrote defense lawyer Bruce Cooper, representing defendant Harun Salhan.
More broadly, defense lawyers and family members of the accused have complained privately that the government’s pursuit of the case is excessive and targets low-level users for whom use of khat is culturally acceptable. And some question whether khat use is a serious problem. In court papers, one defense lawyer presented medical evidence that khat use is no more dangerous than an energy drink.